Date
2022-06-15Author
Schneijderberg, ChristianSubject
370 Education SoziologieWertphilosophieKonventionPrivate KrankenversicherungGesetzliche KrankenversicherungEntwicklungstheorieMetadata
Show full item record
Aufsatz
Socialism Order of Worth and Analytical Adequacy Axiom
Abstract
Boltanski and Thévenot (On justification. Economies of worth, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2006) constructed in their seminal work On Justification the Orders of Worth (OW) framework as a research program for further empirical and theoretical development. This article suggests two methodological additions to extend the analytical capacities of the OW framework: The Socialism OW and the analytical adequacy axiom. The polito-philosophical Socialism OW, which acknowledges '(collective) welfare' as its mode of evaluation (worth) and the higher principle of 'solidarity' as its test, is rooted in the political philosophy of Rosanvallon (The society of equals, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2013). In addition to the systematic justification of the canonical text, this article also offers a tabular presentation for the construction of a new OW in relation to the axioms. In the article, first, the existing OW are put under scrutiny discussing the test category of solidarity, which was added and creates an analytic overload for the Civic OW. Second, analyzing the case of the German binary statutory health system, comprising of a private (first-class) and a public (second-class) healthcare, the capacities of the existing OW are discussed to identify a blank spot in the OW framework for empirical analysis. Accordingly, the descriptive analysis of the German binary health system is less about how the system is justified, and much more about understanding how given OW operate within it as coordinative devices. This systematic analysis of a situation of (temporary) agreements, especially of investments in forms, amends the OW use for empirical analysis of critique and justification in a situation.
Citation
In: Human Studies Volume 45 / Issue 2 (2022-06-15) , S. 283-308 ; eissn:1572-851XSponsorship
Gefördert im Rahmen des Projekts DEALCitation
@article{doi:10.17170/kobra-202207126459,
author={Schneijderberg, Christian},
title={Socialism Order of Worth and Analytical Adequacy Axiom},
journal={Human Studies},
year={2022}
}
0500 Oax 0501 Text $btxt$2rdacontent 0502 Computermedien $bc$2rdacarrier 1100 2022$n2022 1500 1/eng 2050 ##0##http://hdl.handle.net/123456789/14134 3000 Schneijderberg, Christian 4000 Socialism Order of Worth and Analytical Adequacy Axiom / Schneijderberg, Christian 4030 4060 Online-Ressource 4085 ##0##=u http://nbn-resolving.de/http://hdl.handle.net/123456789/14134=x R 4204 \$dAufsatz 4170 5550 {{Soziologie}} 5550 {{Wertphilosophie}} 5550 {{Konvention}} 5550 {{Private Krankenversicherung}} 5550 {{Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung}} 5550 {{Entwicklungstheorie}} 7136 ##0##http://hdl.handle.net/123456789/14134
2022-09-07T13:54:09Z 2022-09-07T13:54:09Z 2022-06-15 doi:10.17170/kobra-202207126459 http://hdl.handle.net/123456789/14134 Gefördert im Rahmen des Projekts DEAL eng Namensnennung 4.0 International http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ axiological sociology Orders of worth public and private health insurance sociology of conventions theory development 370 Socialism Order of Worth and Analytical Adequacy Axiom Aufsatz Boltanski and Thévenot (On justification. Economies of worth, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 2006) constructed in their seminal work On Justification the Orders of Worth (OW) framework as a research program for further empirical and theoretical development. This article suggests two methodological additions to extend the analytical capacities of the OW framework: The Socialism OW and the analytical adequacy axiom. The polito-philosophical Socialism OW, which acknowledges '(collective) welfare' as its mode of evaluation (worth) and the higher principle of 'solidarity' as its test, is rooted in the political philosophy of Rosanvallon (The society of equals, Harvard University Press, Cambridge, 2013). In addition to the systematic justification of the canonical text, this article also offers a tabular presentation for the construction of a new OW in relation to the axioms. In the article, first, the existing OW are put under scrutiny discussing the test category of solidarity, which was added and creates an analytic overload for the Civic OW. Second, analyzing the case of the German binary statutory health system, comprising of a private (first-class) and a public (second-class) healthcare, the capacities of the existing OW are discussed to identify a blank spot in the OW framework for empirical analysis. Accordingly, the descriptive analysis of the German binary health system is less about how the system is justified, and much more about understanding how given OW operate within it as coordinative devices. This systematic analysis of a situation of (temporary) agreements, especially of investments in forms, amends the OW use for empirical analysis of critique and justification in a situation. open access Schneijderberg, Christian doi:10.1007/s10746-022-09629-3 Soziologie Wertphilosophie Konvention Private Krankenversicherung Gesetzliche Krankenversicherung Entwicklungstheorie publishedVersion eissn:1572-851X Issue 2 Human Studies 283-308 Volume 45 false
The following license files are associated with this item: